View basketContact us

Comparison

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 alternatives

Defender for Office 365 is built into Microsoft 365, but it is not the only way to protect your mailboxes. This is a factual look at the alternatives, how each connects, and when it makes sense to run one alongside Microsoft rather than instead of it.

In short

Defender for Office 365 alternatives fall into two groups. API-based products such as Check Point Email Security, IRONSCALES, FortiMail Workspace Security and Barracuda Integrated Email Protection connect inside the tenant after Microsoft's filtering. Secure email gateways such as Proofpoint Essentials filter mail before it arrives. Most organisations run an alternative alongside Defender rather than replacing it.

Want an impartial recommendation?

Tell us about your users, systems and priorities and we will tell you which option fits, and why.

Contact us for free advice or a quote

The alternatives at a glance

These are the options we most often compare with Microsoft's own protection, described from each vendor's public material.

The alternatives at a glance
OptionHow it connectsNotable forMore detail
Check Point Email Security (opens in a new tab) (formerly Harmony Email & Collaboration)API inside the tenant, no MX change; from monitor mode through to inline preventionA second detection engine for every message, including internal mail; Google Workspace, Slack, Box, Dropbox and ShareFile coverageCheck Point vs Defender (opens in a new tab)
IRONSCALESAPI, no MX changeMailbox-level BEC and phishing detection with automatic remediation, designed to work alongside Microsoft's protectionIRONSCALES
FortiMail Workspace Security (formerly Perception Point)API integration, or a browser extension for the browser componentEmail, browser and collaboration protection, with an incident response service that Fortinet includesFortiMail Workspace Security
Barracuda Email ProtectionIntegrated Email Protection by API with no MX change, or the Email Gateway Defense gatewayImpersonation and account takeover protection, Incident Response and DMARC reporting; higher plans add Microsoft 365 backup and archivingBarracuda Email Protection
Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection (Proofpoint 365 Total Protection)MX, API or Hybrid mode, the last checking mail before and after deliveryA Microsoft 365 suite in four plans, from filtering and encryption up to archiving, backup, DMARC Manager and Teams ProtectionHornetsecurity 365 Total Protection
Mimecast email securityMX-based gateway, or API with no MX changeCritical, Advanced and Premium plans, with continuity in the gateway deployment and collaboration tool protection in PremiumMimecast email security
Fortinet FortiMailFortiMail Cloud as a gateway, by Microsoft Graph API with no MX change, or bothPost-delivery clawback by API; DLP, encryption and sandboxing in the Gateway Premium packages; Fortinet Security Fabric integrationFortinet FortiMail
Proofpoint EssentialsCloud gateway: MX records point at ProofpointDLP and continuity in every package, encryption from Advanced and a ten-year archive in ProfessionalProofpoint Essentials
TrendAI Vision One Email and Collaboration Security (Trend Micro)API with an optional inline mode, an MX gateway, or bothExchange Online, OneDrive, SharePoint and Teams, plus Google Workspace, Box and DropboxTrend Micro email security
Cisco Secure Email Threat Defense (formerly Cloud Mailbox Defense)Journaling and Microsoft APIs, no MX change (Essentials); an inline gateway in the Advantage editionRuns alongside Microsoft 365's built-in protection with Cisco Talos threat intelligence; fits organisations standardising on Cisco securityCisco Secure Email Threat Defense (opens in a new tab)
Sophos EmailMicrosoft 365 integration with no MX change, or a cloud gateway, managed in Sophos CentralOrganisations already using Sophos endpoint or MDRSophos Email (opens in a new tab)

Every platform we supply is set out side by side on email security platforms compared.

Still not sure which way to go? Ask us

Tell us what matters most to you and we will recommend one, with the trade-offs explained.

Contact us for free advice or a quote

Is Defender for Office 365 enough on its own?

It is a strong baseline when it is configured well, and we can configure it for you. Defender for Office 365 is part of Microsoft's own service, so there is nothing to connect and policies are managed in the Defender portal alongside your other Microsoft security. According to Microsoft, Plan 1, included in subscriptions such as Microsoft 365 Business Premium and Microsoft 365 E3, brings impersonation protection, Safe Links and Safe Attachments, including for files in SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams. Plan 2 adds Threat Explorer, automated investigation and response, attack simulation training and incident investigation in Microsoft Defender XDR (opens in a new tab). Our Microsoft 365 phishing protection guide covers the policies to set, and our sister site explains Microsoft Defender for Office 365 (opens in a new tab) plan by plan.

An alternative or extra layer usually earns its place when one of these applies:

  • You are heavily targeted by phishing and invoice fraud and want an independent second opinion on every message, not a stronger version of the same one
  • You use Google Workspace, Slack or third-party file sharing, which Defender for Office 365 does not cover
  • You want continuity, a compliance archive or encryption from the same supplier
  • You want a managed service watching email and user-reported phishing for you

API layer or gateway?

The architecture matters more than any single feature.

  • API-based products connect to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace after an administrator grants consent. Microsoft's or Google's own filtering still runs first; the product then applies its own detection to each message, including internal mail, and can remove messages from every inbox after delivery. There is no MX change, which is why they so often run alongside Defender.
  • Secure email gateways sit in front of your mail service. Your MX records point at the gateway, mail is filtered before Microsoft receives it, and Exchange Online is then locked down to accept inbound mail only from the gateway. Exchange Online Protection keeps running behind it. Gateways bring extras such as continuity, archiving and outbound filtering.
  • Hybrid products do both. Hornetsecurity's Hybrid mode checks mail before and after delivery, Barracuda offers both an API product (Integrated Email Protection) and a gateway (Email Gateway Defense) in its Email Protection plans, and Trend Micro can combine API and gateway deployment.

Ask any vendor exactly when a message is inspected, whether it can be held before the user sees it, and what happens if the connection to the tenant is interrupted. Our ICES vs SEG comparison sets the two architectures side by side.

Weighing up the options?

We can compare them against your own requirements and recommend what fits.

Contact us for free advice or a quote

Check Point Email Security as an option

Avanan was acquired by Check Point in 2021. The product, sold for a time as Harmony Email & Collaboration, is now Check Point Email Security, and it is the alternative most often trialled beside Defender. Check Point says it enforces protection from monitor mode to inline prevention: in monitor mode it reports what it would have caught without touching mail flow, and in inline prevention it inspects each message after Microsoft's filtering and before it reaches the inbox. Its packages cover Email Only or Email & Collaboration, in two tiers: Advanced Protect, with phishing and account takeover protection, URL emulation, sandboxing and attachment sanitisation (CDR), and Complete Protect, which adds data loss prevention.

Check Point Email Security as an option
App or platformDefender for Office 365Check Point Email Security
Exchange Online mailYesYes
Microsoft Teams, SharePoint and OneDriveYesYes, with Email & Collaboration coverage
Gmail and Google Drive (Google Workspace)NoYes
SlackNoYes
Box, Dropbox, ShareFileNoYes

The full head-to-head, including investigation tools, add-ons and licensing, is on our Check Point site: Check Point vs Defender for Office 365, with the product itself under Check Point Email Security (opens in a new tab).

Running an alternative alongside Defender

Running two layers is a deliberate, common design rather than duplication. A typical pattern for an API product is:

  1. Keep Exchange Online Protection and Defender for Office 365 configured with the preset security policies
  2. Connect the second layer by API in monitor mode and compare its findings with what Defender caught for a few weeks
  3. Switch it to prevention and agree which product quarantines what, so users are not confused
  4. Route user-reported phishing to one place and make sure someone triages it, either your team or a managed service

With a gateway, the extra step is the mail-flow change: connectors, MX records and locking Exchange Online to the gateway, done at a quiet time. Microsoft recommends enabling the Standard and/or Strict preset security policies for all users, which matches what we advise. Pricing for every option depends on what you already own, the package and the number of users, so ask us for a quote.

Which should you choose?

The pattern is consistent:

  • Defender for Office 365 alone suits Microsoft-only organisations that already own it, configure it well and have someone, internal or managed, using the Defender portal.
  • An API layer alongside Defender suits organisations heavily targeted by phishing and invoice fraud, those wanting an independent second engine, and those sharing sensitive data through collaboration apps. Check Point, IRONSCALES, FortiMail Workspace Security and Barracuda Integrated Email Protection all fit here.
  • An API product as the main layer suits Google Workspace organisations, mixed Microsoft and Google estates and businesses using Slack or third-party file sharing.
  • A gateway or a hybrid suite suits organisations that want continuity, an archive and encryption from one supplier, such as Proofpoint Essentials or Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection.

Whichever you choose, configuration matters more than the logo: preset policies, impersonation protection, an enforced DMARC (opens in a new tab) policy and a tested process for user reports.

How we help

We supply several of these products, so we can run a side-by-side comparison on your own mail. We review your current Defender configuration, connect a second layer in monitor mode for a trial where the product supports it, show you what each caught, and then recommend the combination that fits, with the licences for the third-party product confirmed at quote.

Contact us to arrange a side-by-side trial.

How Forever Systems helps with email security

We are an independent UK IT and cyber security provider. We supply several email security platforms, so we can suggest what suits your mail system, your risks and your budget.

  • Start with what you have: we can review the protection already built into Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace before suggesting anything extra
  • Compare like for like: API-based protection, secure email gateways and email filtering, encryption services and DLP from the vendors we supply, explained in plain English
  • Get authentication right: we help you plan SPF, DKIM, DMARC and MTA-STS so genuine mail is delivered and spoofed mail is not
  • Deployment help: connecting a platform to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, mail routing changes and policy set-up, scoped at quote
  • Email signatures: one approved signature and disclaimer on every email with Exclaimer email signature management
  • People and backup too: security awareness training, Check Point Email Security and Sophos from our specialist sites

Tell us about your mail system and we will suggest options, with pricing confirmed at quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is Defender for Office 365 enough on its own?

It is a strong baseline once the preset policies, impersonation protection and user reporting are configured and someone acts on incidents, all of which we can set up. A second layer adds protection if you are heavily targeted by phishing or invoice fraud, use Google Workspace or Slack, or want continuity, archiving or a managed service.

What are the alternatives to Defender for Office 365?

API-based products such as Check Point Email Security, IRONSCALES, FortiMail Workspace Security, Barracuda Integrated Email Protection and Cisco Secure Email Threat Defense, and secure email gateways such as Proofpoint Essentials, Cisco Secure Email Gateway and Sophos Email. Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection is a Microsoft 365 suite that runs in MX, API or Hybrid mode.

What does Check Point Email Security add to Microsoft 365?

A second, independent detection engine that inspects every message, including internal mail, after Microsoft's filtering, and can hold suspicious mail before it reaches the inbox in inline prevention. It also extends the same protection to Google Workspace, Slack, Box, Dropbox and ShareFile, and Complete Protect adds data loss prevention.

Can you run Check Point Email Security alongside Defender for Office 365?

Yes, and many organisations do. It connects by API and inspects mail after Microsoft's filtering, so Defender keeps working underneath. The usual approach is a monitor-mode trial, then inline prevention with clear rules on which product quarantines what.

Which is easier to manage?

Defender for Office 365 is simplest for teams that already work in the Defender portal: one console, one set of incidents and one licence relationship with Microsoft. An alternative adds a second console, but API products need no mail-flow change, and some include a vendor service that handles alerts and user reports.

Do I need to change MX records?

Not for Defender for Office 365 or API-based products such as Check Point Email Security, IRONSCALES, FortiMail Workspace Security and Barracuda Integrated Email Protection. A secure email gateway such as Proofpoint Essentials does need an MX change, plus connectors and a lock-down so Exchange Online only accepts mail from the gateway.

Still deciding?

Ask us and a member of our team will get back to you.

Contact us for free advice or a quote

Next step

Want help choosing an email security platform?

Tell us what you need and we will come back to you with options and next steps.

  1. 1
    Tell us what you needA few lines is enough: your organisation, users or sites, and timescales.
  2. 2
    We read it and get back to youWith options and clear next steps.
  3. 3
    You decideChoose the option that suits you and we take it from there.

Send a quick enquiry

A few lines is enough.

About: Defender for Office 365 alternatives

We use these details to reply to your enquiry. Privacy notice

Talk to us about Defender for Office 365 alternatives

For businesses and organisations. A few lines is enough.

We use these details to reply to your enquiry. Privacy notice
Talk to us aboutDefender for Office 365 alternatives
Contact us